CVNA Institutional Collar Strategy - Smart Money Hedges $11M Position! - September 24, 2025

---

🏢 Company Overview

Carvana Co. (CVNA)
- Description: Carvana Co is an e-commerce platform for buying and selling used cars.
- Market Cap: $52.2B
- Sector: Retail-Auto Dealers & Gasoline Stations

---

🎯 The Quick Take

Someone just executed a $11.5M collar strategy on Carvana at 11:16:45 AM today! This massive institutional play bought $1.3M in puts while selling $8.2M in calls (both at $310 strike expiring November 21). With earnings coming October 29th and the stock up 4,000% in two years, this is classic profit protection. Translation: Big money is locking in gains while staying long!

---

💰 The Option Flow Breakdown

📊 What Just Happened

The Tape (September 24, 2025 @ 11:16:45):

Time	Symbol	Side	Buy/Sell	Type	Expiration	Premium	Strike	Volume	OI	Size	Spot	Option Price
11:16:45	CVNA	MID	BUY	PUT	2025-11-21	$1.3M	$310	1K	740	1,000	$376.64	$12.74
11:16:45	CVNA	MID	SELL	CALL	2025-11-21	$8.2M	$310	1K	82	1,000	$376.64	$81.99

Net Credit: $69.25 per contract = $6.9M total collected ($81.99 - $12.74 = $69.25 × 1,000 contracts)

🤓 What This Actually Means

This is a collar strategy - the smart money way to protect massive gains! The trader:

• Owns significant CVNA stock (likely 100,000+ shares)
• Bought downside protection at $310 (limits losses to -17.7%)
• Sold upside at $310 (caps gains but collects huge premium)
• Pocketed $6.9M in cash upfront to reduce cost basis
• Protected against earnings volatility (October 29th)

Unusual Score: EXTREME 🔥 (1,590x average size) - This is UNPRECEDENTED! We're talking about activity that happens maybe once a year for CVNA!

---

📈 Technical Setup / Chart Check-Up

YTD Chart

Carvana has been on an absolute tear! The stock has exploded from bankruptcy fears to profitability, currently trading around $376. This remarkable turnaround from near-zero to current levels represents one of the greatest comebacks in market history.

Key observations:
- Monster recovery: From $3.55 low (Dec 2022) to $376 today
- YTD performance: Stock maintaining strong momentum in 2025
- Market cap: Now at $52.2B - back to unicorn status
- Volatility: High IV reflects continued uncertainty despite gains

Gamma-Based Support & Resistance Analysis

Current Price: $372.67

The gamma landscape reveals critical levels for this massive trade:

Key Support Levels:
- 🔵 $370: Strongest support (0.72% below) - Heavy put gamma concentration
- 🔵 $360: Secondary floor (3.40% below) - Additional put wall
- 🔵 $355: Major support (4.74% below) - Massive put gamma buildup
- 🔵 $350: Ultimate floor (6.08% below) - Institution-level support

Key Resistance Levels:
- 🟠 $375: Immediate resistance (0.62% above) - First call wall
- 🟠 $380: Strong resistance (1.97% above) - Major call gamma concentration
- 🟠 $385: Heavy resistance (3.31% above) - Largest call gamma wall
- 🟠 $390: Key level (4.65% above) - Significant dealer hedging zone
- 🟠 $400: Psychological barrier (7.33% above) - Round number resistance

Gamma Bias: BULLISH (Net positive call gamma dominance)

The $310 strike chosen for this collar sits well below current support levels, suggesting the trader expects volatility but not a complete collapse. Smart positioning!

---

🎪 Catalysts

Upcoming Events

Q3 2025 Earnings - October 29, 2025
- MarketBeat consensus expects continued profitability momentum
- Focus on GPU improvements from Q2's impressive $7,344 per unit
- Analysts project $1.1B EBITDA for full year 2024

Market Expansion Initiatives
- 3 million unit sales target over next 5-10 years (10% market share)
- New car sales via dealership acquisitions including Dallas franchise

Technology Improvements
- AI-powered Carli system enhancements ongoing
- Logistics optimization driving margin expansion

Recently Completed

Debt Restructuring Success
- $5.2B debt restructuring reduced annual interest by $430M
- Debt-to-EBITDA improved from 18.8x to 4.2x
- Financial flexibility restored for growth investments

Q2 2025 Record Results
- $4.84B revenue with 6.4% net margin (41.9% YoY growth)
- $308M GAAP net income
- 143,280 retail units sold (up 41% YoY)

---

🎲 Price Targets & Probabilities

Based on gamma levels and catalyst analysis:

🚀 Bull Case (25% chance)

Target: $400-$430
- Break above $385 gamma resistance triggers squeeze
- Strong earnings beat with GPU expansion
- Market share gains accelerate beyond expectations
- Debt reduction ahead of schedule

😐 Base Case (50% chance)

Target: $360-$385
- Range-bound between major gamma levels
- Steady execution on profitability metrics
- Normal seasonal patterns hold
- Collar strategy suggests institutional expectation

😰 Bear Case (25% chance)

Target: $350-$355
- Tests major put support at $355
- Macro headwinds impact used car demand
- Rising interest rates pressure subprime buyers
- Profit-taking after massive rally

---

💡 Trading Ideas

🛡️ Conservative: "Follow the Smart Money"

• Strategy: Buy CVNA shares + protective puts
• Entry: Buy stock at $375, buy Nov $350 puts for $8
• Risk: Limited to $33/share (8.8%)
• Reward: Unlimited upside above $383
• Why it works: Similar to institutional collar but with more upside

⚖️ Balanced: "Gamma Squeeze Play"

• Strategy: Bull call spread
• Entry: Buy Oct 18 $380/$400 call spread for $7.50
• Max profit: $12.50 (167% return)
• Max loss: $7.50 premium paid
• Why it works: Targets resistance levels with defined risk

🚀 Aggressive: "YOLO the Breakout"

• Strategy: Buy weekly $385 calls
• Entry: Oct 4 $385 calls at $4.50
• Risk: 100% of premium
• Reward: Explosive if breaks gamma wall
• Why it works: Cheap lottery tickets on momentum

---

⚠️ Risk Factors

Real talk - here's what could go wrong:

• 📉 Valuation concerns: P/E at 107 leaves no room for error
• 💳 Debt burden: Despite restructuring, 239% debt-to-equity ratio remains elevated
• 📊 Market sensitivity: Used car demand vulnerable to recession
• 🏦 Interest rate risk: Subprime auto loans under pressure
• 🎢 Volatility: Stock can move 10-20% on any headline

---

🎯 The Bottom Line

Here's the deal: When someone drops $11.5M on a collar strategy, they're not gambling - they're protecting serious money. This trade screams "we love the long-term story but earnings could be volatile."

Action Plan:

📈 If you own CVNA: Consider taking some profits or hedging like the pros
👀 If you're watching: Wait for a pullback to $355-360 support
🐻 If you're bearish: The $310 put floor suggests limited downside near-term

Mark your calendar: October 29th earnings will be the next major catalyst. Until then, expect range-bound action between $360-385 with that massive collar acting as a volatility dampener.

The unusualness score of 1,590x average tells us this isn't your typical retail trade - this is institutional money making a calculated move. When the smart money hedges this aggressively after a 4,000% rally, maybe it's time we pay attention! 🎯

---

Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. This analysis is for educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. Always do your own research and consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.